Can a New York Non-Party Witness Be Compelled to Testify at a Civil Trial in California?
Our New York Law Firm Can Help Obtain Non-Party Deposition Testimony in New York for Use at a Civil Trial in California
An attorney handling a civil lawsuit in California may need testimony from a non-party witness who is located in New York. However, if the witness is not subject to a California court’s jurisdiction, the New York non-party witness generally cannot be compelled to travel to California to testify at a civil trial or hearing.
New York’s Uniform Interstate Depositions and Discovery
Act (UIDDA) Can Help California Attorneys
New York’s version of the Uniform Interstate Depositions and Discovery Act (UIDDA) provides a procedure to obtain discovery from individuals and companies located in New York for use in civil lawsuits pending in California.
Under N.Y. CPLR 3119(a)(4), a New York attorney (such as our law firm) may issue a subpoena pursuant to New York’s version of the UIDDA that will require the New York non-party witness to: (i) attend and give testimony at a deposition; (ii) produce documents, records, electronically stored information, or other designated materials; or (iii) permit inspection of premises under the witness’s control.
However, New York’s UIDDA does not allow a New York
subpoena to compel a non-party witness to travel to California to testify at a civil trial or hearing. But
there is a solution.
The Solution: Deposing the Non-Party Witness in New York Before the California Civil Trial
Although a non-party witness in New York generally cannot be compelled to travel to another state to testify at a civil trial in California, the witness may be compelled to provide deposition testimony in New York, and the transcript or video recording may be used in the California litigation, subject to the applicable California civil procedure governing admissibility.
Under New York’s UIDDA, a New York attorney retained by a party involved in a civil lawsuit pending in California may issue a New York subpoena based on a properly issued California subpoena. This procedure allows attorneys handling litigation in California to obtain testimony from non-party witnesses located in New York without requiring those witnesses to appear personally at a civil trial in California or hearing.
It is important to conduct the deposition before the discovery deadline, if any, for the California lawsuit expires.
Using the New York Deposition Transcript at a Trial in California
Virtually all states permit the deposition testimony of a non-party witness to be introduced at trial when the witness is not subject to a California court’s jurisdiction, subject to certain conditions.
Proper notice of the deposition to all parties and an opportunity for those parties to examine the witness during the deposition are generally required.
Before proceeding with the deposition of a New York
non-party witness, the California attorney handling the
California litigation should research the
procedural/evidentiary laws of California where the civil
trial will take place to ensure that all parties receive
proper notice, an opportunity to participate in the New York
deposition of the non-party witness, and otherwise comply
with local procedural law. California counsel should review the applicable California law, including, but not limited to, Cal. Civ. Proc. Code § 2025.620(c)(1), (c)(2)(D)–(E) and Cal. Evid. Code § 1291. (California counsel should make his or
her own assessment of what is required under California
law for admissibility of a deposition transcript at a civil trial in California and perform further independent research,
if needed; do not rely exclusively on this cited law).
How Our New York Law Firm Can Help California Attorneys
Peter M. Agulnick, P.C. assists California attorneys in obtaining deposition testimony and other discovery from non-party witnesses located in New York.
Our law firm can serve as local New York counsel and assist with:
- Issuing New York subpoenas pursuant to New York’s UIDDA;
- Arranging for service of subpoenas upon New York non-party witnesses;
- Coordinating depositions, including arranging stenographers and deposition facilities;
- Arranging depositions conducted by video conference; and
- Seeking judicial enforcement when a witness fails or refuses to comply with a properly issued and served New York subpoena.
When necessary, our law firm can seek a New York court order compelling a non-party witness to attend a deposition or request that the witness be held in contempt of court for failing to comply with a lawful subpoena.
California Attorneys May Contact Our Law Firm for a Free Consultation
If you are an attorney handling a civil lawsuit in California and need testimony or documents from a non-party witness located in New York, call the law firm of Peter M. Agulnick, P.C. at 212-571-2266 for a free consultation.
